Indianapolis, IN · Junk car buyers
8 Best Junk Car Buyers in Indianapolis, IN That Pay Cash for Cars
By Clunqr Team, Clunqr Benchmark Data · Updated September 24, 2026 · 8 Indianapolis buyers, checked against physical addresses and seller reviews
Looking for a junk car buyer in Indianapolis that pays cash for cars? Here are 8 of them, with phone numbers, from Yandes Street and the near east side out to Raceway Road and the south side. All eight pay cash for junk cars, including wrecked, non-running and totaled vehicles. We compared each on what they want in a vehicle, whether they tow it away for free, how fast they collect, and what to sort out before you book a pickup.
Key takeaways
- Here are 8 junk car buyers in Indianapolis that pay cash for cars, all of them listed below with addresses and phone numbers.
- Three publish free towing or removal: Pull-A-Part on Producers Avenue, Clayton's on the southeast side and Cash For Junk Wrecked Cars, which comes to you anywhere in the metro. Ask the rest who pays for the tow.
- Cash For Junk Wrecked Cars holds a 4.9 across 276 reviews with same-day pickup and cash on the spot, and Max handles the buying and the driving himself. When one person does both, the quote and the payment are the same conversation.
- One Way Auto Parts went from phone quote to cash in three hours for one seller on the near east side. If speed is the thing you actually care about, that is the documented benchmark here.
- Indiana plates stay with you, not the car. Pull them before the truck leaves, keep a bill of sale, and have photo ID ready, because every buyer here will ask for it.
We buy junk cars in Indianapolis too, so read this knowing that. Get our number first, then call two or three of the buyers below. We think we will win on price and on not wasting your afternoon. If somebody beats us, take it.
Get an instant cash offer for your junk car in Indianapolis
Two minutes on the Clunqr form, or call the AI agent and describe the car out loud: year, make, condition, what is wrong with it. We pay cash, we tow for free across Marion County, and you get cash today on most same-day pickups. You will have a real price in minutes, which gives you something to measure the other eight against.
Backed by the Clunqr Guarantee
The price you accept is the price you're paid, towing across the Indianapolis metro is free, and your phone number and address stay private until you choose who takes the car. If anyone no-shows, renegotiates in your driveway, or pays a dollar less than agreed, Clunqr makes it right or pays the difference.
Here Are 8 of the Best Junk Car Buyers in Indianapolis
All eight buy junk cars for cash, and we don't rank them. Search junkyards near me in Indianapolis and you get a map full of pins with no way to tell which ones buy vehicles, so this is that list. The right one depends on what your car is, which side of the city you are on, and how fast you need it gone. Wrecked, non-running and totaled cars and trucks are routine for every buyer here. Call two or three, because the quotes you get back will not be the same. How a buyer arrives at a number when buying junk cars for cash is worth understanding before the first call.
| Buyer | Rating | Best for | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash For Junk Wrecked CarsJunk car buyer · Yandes St, MidtownBuys junk cars | 4.9276 reviews | Same-day cash anywhere in the metroA 4.9 across 276 reviews and the highest-rated junk car buyer in the city, working out of Yandes Street near Midtown. Max is the buyer and the driver, so the person quoting you is the person handing over the money, which removes the gap where quotes usually move. Call, get a number, and it happens the same day.Towing: Comes to you · Pickup: Same day · Payment: Cash on the spotBefore you go: Confirm the pickup window and check the coverage reaches your address. Have your photo ID and title ready before the truck arrives. | 2455 Yandes St, Indianapolis, IN 46205(317) 909-2277cashforjunkwreckedcars.com |
| One Way Auto PartsSalvage yard · E New York St, near east sideBuys junk cars | 4.534 reviews | Speed, on the near east sideBuys junk cars on East New York Street with a straightforward process and a documented turnaround: one seller got a phone quote, had the car collected and was paid within three hours. Shawn is named by four separate reviewers for handling transactions cleanly with no wasted time.Towing: Ask · Pickup: Same day available · Payment: CashBefore you go: Ask for a phone quote and the pickup window in the same call, and confirm whether the tow is inside the offer. | 3401 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46201(317) 632-1994one-wayautoparts.com |
| Pull-A-Part IndianapolisSalvage yard · Producers Ave, near northeastBuys junk cars | 4.41,500 reviews | Free junk car towing, near northeastThe most reviewed operation on this page at 1,500, on Producers Avenue, buying junk cars with free towing alongside a clean, well-organized yard. Liz and Deborah handled one junk car purchase and went out of their way to translate for a Spanish-speaking seller working through the paperwork.Towing: Free · Pickup: Ask · Payment: AskBefore you go: Free towing is published with the buying programme, so confirm it covers your address and make sure you are talking to the car buying side rather than the parts counter. | 2505 Producers Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218(317) 542-7750pullapart.com |
| Clayton's Auto PartsSalvage yard · Southeastern Ave, southeast IndianapolisBuys junk cars | 4.270 reviews | The southeast side, free removalA father-and-son operation on Southeastern Avenue offering free junk car removal. What the reviews keep returning to is honesty rather than price, which is a strange thing for people to volunteer about a salvage yard and usually means the number quoted is the number paid.Towing: Free removal · Pickup: Ask · Payment: AskBefore you go: Free removal is advertised, so confirm it covers your address, and ask about the payment method and what paperwork they need. | 3420 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203(317) 357-0700 |
| The New Country Auto PartsSalvage yard · Stanley Ave, south sideBuys junk cars | 4.8292 reviews | The south side, and scrap in the same tripThe highest-rated full-service yard in the city, on Stanley Avenue, buying junk cars and handling scrap metal and appliance recycling under the same roof. Mark is named for remembering customers by name across years. The one to call if you have a car and a pile of metal to move at the same time.Towing: Ask · Pickup: Ask · Payment: CashBefore you go: Ask who pays for the tow and confirm the payment method, and mention any scrap metal going at the same time. | 3013 Stanley Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227(317) 787-7555thenewcountryautoparts.com |
| Indy U-Pull-ItSalvage yard · W 16th St, near northwest sideBuys junk cars | 4.22,105 reviews | Volume, and the near northwest sideIndianapolis's original self-service yard, 1,200-plus vehicles with over 50 fresh cars rotating in daily, open seven days. One seller whose car died got an offer call and had it collected the next day at a better price than the online valuation tools had suggested, which is worth noting given how often those tools set expectations.Towing: Ask · Pickup: Next day documented · Payment: CashBefore you go: Ask for the vehicle buying side rather than the general counter, and confirm who pays for the tow and how you are paid. | 940 W 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202(317) 925-2277indyupullit.com |
| Indianapolis Auto PartsSalvage yard · Raceway Rd, west IndianapolisBuys junk cars | 4.2401 reviews | The west side, bilingual serviceA full-service yard on Raceway Road buying junk cars, with bilingual staff throughout rather than one person who happens to speak Spanish. Dayanna, Flor and Leah are named individually. The nearest buyer on this page if you are out near Avon, Speedway or along I-70 west.Towing: Ask · Pickup: Ask · Payment: AskBefore you go: Ask about the buying process and who pays for the tow, and confirm the payment method before you agree a price. | 520 N Raceway Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46234(317) 925-8520autopartsindy.com |
| Two Little Bee's Auto PartsSalvage yard · S Tibbs Ave, west IndianapolisBuys junk cars | 4.1290 reviews | Newer vehicles, 1999 onwardA full-service yard on South Tibbs Avenue buying junk cars, working across vehicles from 1999 onward with VIN-level verification on what comes out of them. One customer was quoted $106 on the phone and paid $50 on arrival, which is the rare direction for a number to move in this trade.Towing: Ask · Pickup: Ask · Payment: AskBefore you go: Have the year and VIN ready, since they work to VIN-level detail. Confirm the towing terms and payment method. | 507 S Tibbs Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46241(317) 243-7777twobeesparts.com |
Hours, service areas, towing terms and paperwork rules change often. Confirm the details, and the net amount you'll be handed, before you schedule a pickup.
How do you sell a junk car for cash in Indianapolis?
The sequence is the same whichever buyer you use. Describe the car accurately, gather more than one number, compare what you net after towing, sign the title over, and take payment before the car leaves.
- 1
Write down the truth about the car
Year, make, model, mileage, condition, what runs and what is missing. Selling your car goes wrong when a buyer finds a surprise on site, because that is what gets the offer cut in the driveway.
- 2
Get more than one quote
Never work from a single number. Three of the eight will collect without charging you for it, so the first round of quotes costs phone calls rather than drives, and an instant cash offer online gives you another in about two minutes. One seller here found the yard beat what the online valuation tools had told him to expect.
- 3
Compare after towing
Cash For Junk Wrecked Cars comes to you, Pull-A-Part publishes free towing with its buying programme, and Clayton's advertises free junk car removal. The other five do not publish towing terms, and a courtesy tow usually comes back out of your offer, so ask for the net cash figure.
- 4
Sign the title, pull the plates
Title signed over, bill of sale for your records, plates off before the truck leaves. Indiana plates belong to you rather than the car, and they can go on your next vehicle.
- 5
Get paid first
Payment confirmed before the junk vehicle is loaded, then cancel the insurance. Every buyer here will want photo ID, so have it out before the driver arrives rather than hunting for it while a truck idles.
Before the truck arrives: have your title and photo ID ready, remove the plates, take out your belongings, and don't cancel insurance until the car is gone.
Indianapolis junk car selling questions
Who buys junk cars for cash in Indianapolis?
All eight buyers on this page pay cash for junk cars, and wrecked, non-running and totaled vehicles are routine for every one of them. Cash For Junk Wrecked Cars holds a 4.9 across 276 reviews and comes to you anywhere in the metro. Pull-A-Part on Producers Avenue and Clayton's on the southeast side both publish free towing. One Way, New Country, Indy U-Pull-It, Indianapolis Auto Parts and Two Little Bee's cover the east, south and west sides.
How fast can I get a junk car picked up in Indianapolis?
Same day is realistic with the right buyer. The documented benchmark here is One Way Auto Parts on East New York Street, where one seller got a phone quote, had the car collected and was paid within three hours. Cash For Junk Wrecked Cars publishes same-day pickup with cash on the spot, and Max handles both the quote and the collection himself. Indy U-Pull-It collected one seller's car the next day after an offer call.
Will an Indianapolis junk car buyer tow my car for free?
Three of the eight will. Cash For Junk Wrecked Cars comes to you across the metro, Pull-A-Part on Producers Avenue publishes free junk car towing as part of its buying programme, and Clayton's on Southeastern Avenue advertises free removal. The other five do not publish towing terms, so ask, because a buyer that tows as a courtesy usually takes the cost back out of your offer.
What paperwork do I need to junk a car in Indiana?
The Indiana title signed over to the buyer, your photo ID, and a bill of sale you keep a copy of. Photo ID is standard at every buyer here, not optional. Remove your plates before the truck leaves, because in Indiana they belong to you rather than the car and can be transferred to your next vehicle. Cancel the insurance after pickup rather than before. The full checklist is in what you need to sell a car to a junkyard.
Should I trust an online junk car valuation in Indianapolis?
Treat it as a floor rather than a ceiling. One seller here had a car die, took an offer call from Indy U-Pull-It and was collected the next day at a better price than the online valuation tools had suggested. Those tools work from averages and cannot see your specific car, your location or what a particular yard happens to be short of that week. Use one to sanity-check a number, then call two or three buyers and find out what it is actually worth.
Should I call more than one Indianapolis junk car buyer?
Yes. Three of these will come to you without charging for it, so a round of quotes costs you phone calls rather than an afternoon. Ask each for the net amount after towing rather than the headline figure, have your photo ID ready because every buyer here asks for it, and do not treat an online valuation as the answer, since at least one seller here was paid more than the tools predicted.
Junk car buyers in nearby cities
Selling somewhere else, or willing to look further out? These are the closest cities we have covered, with the same phone numbers and towing terms for each buyer.
Somewhere else entirely? See every city we cover.
More on selling a junk car
These come up on every junk car sale, not just in Indianapolis, so each one is covered in full on its own page rather than repeated here.
Clunqr Team · Clunqr Benchmark Data
This guide is maintained by the Clunqr data team from local listings, seller reviews and the physical addresses of each buyer. Every operation listed here was checked against a real street address before it went on the page. Last updated September 24, 2026.